Fauci vs Kardashian: the public prefers health tips from experts

Article written by Gary Finnegan.

People are more willing to reshare calls for social distancing if the message is endorsed by a well-known expert – such as US immunologist Dr Anthony Fauci – rather than a government spokesperson or a celebrity, according to a new study.

The international survey conducted by Ahmad Abu-Akel of the West University of Lausanne, and Andreas Spitz and Robert West of the École Polytechnique Fédérale de Lausanne, was published in PLOS ONE.  

Previous research has extensively explored how to maximize the effectiveness of public health messages by altering their style and content. However, relatively few studies have examined the impact of spokesperson identity on the effectiveness of health messages, especially during crises like the ongoing COVID-19 pandemic.

To better understand this impact, the team conducted a survey of 12,194 people from six countries in March of 2020. The survey was framed as an evaluation of people’s perspectives on the pandemic.

It included a question about participants’ willingness to share a message that encouraged social distancing, ostensibly endorsed by one of four randomly selected spokespersons: Fauci, Tom Hanks (who had notably contracted COVID-19), Kim Kardashian, or a prominent government official from the survey taker’s country.

The researchers found that, across all six countries (Brazil, Italy, South Korea, Spain, Switzerland, and the U.S.), participants reported greater willingness to share the social-distancing message if told it was endorsed by Fauci versus any of the other three spokespersons. This preference held true after accounting for participants’ varying demographics and attitudes towards social distancing.

Endorsement by the celebrities was less likely to prompt willingness to share than endorsement by a government official, or no endorsement at all. Participants who were older or reported positive sentiments toward their randomly selected spokesperson were more likely to be willing to share the message.

These findings could help guide governments’ selection of the best spokespeople to convey public health messages in order to maximize their effectiveness, for example to encourage vaccine acceptance. Future research could examine the impact of other spokespersons, such as religious leaders, and explore which traits make certain spokespersons more effective than others.

‘Identifying and empowering liked and trusted experts is a key component of effective public health communication during the ongoing pandemic, and it is likely preferable to using celebrity advocates,’ the authors said.